Rigby Teen Elintra Fischer Resurfaces in Utah After 3 Years Missing

RIGBY, Idaho — Elintra Fischer, who disappeared from Jefferson County over three years ago alongside siblings Rachelle Leray Fischer, then 15, and Allen Larand Fischer, then 13, has reappeared in Utah. The Jefferson County Sheriff’s Office announced Friday that Elintra obtained a driver’s license there, prompting investigators to remove her from the National Crime Information Center as a missing person. "Our office is still interested in speaking with Elintra," the sheriff’s statement read.

The siblings vanished from their Monteview home, about 50 miles northwest of Idaho Falls, on an unspecified Sunday in 2023, sparking an AMBER Alert. Authorities initially believed the teens, tied to FLDS religious beliefs, were heading to Utah in a gray Honda or Hyundai with Utah plates, though no evidence confirmed the vehicle’s presence in Idaho. Rachelle, 5-foot-5 with brown hair and blue eyes, was last seen in a dark green prairie dress with braided hair; Allen, 5-foot-9, 135 pounds with sandy blonde hair and blue eyes, wore a light blue shirt, jeans and black Crocs. A $5,000 reward was offered for information.

Rachelle and Allen remain listed as missing, with the investigation active. The sheriff’s office urges tips at (208) 745-9210. This eastern Idaho community, marked by rural Jefferson County’s vast farmlands, continues to seek closure in a case that echoes other unresolved disappearances like Idaho Falls teen Jed Hall’s 2018 vanishing.