North Manatee Soccer Club Treasurer Nancy Fetzner Arrested for Allegedly Misusing Over $146K in Funds

Myakka City residents are discussing the arrest of Nancy Fetzner, 52, the former treasurer of the North Manatee Soccer Club. Authorities charged Fetzner with Scheme to Defraud $50,000 or more after an investigation revealed she allegedly misused over $146,000 in club funds for personal expenses.

This news directly impacts local families involved with the North Manatee Soccer Club, raising questions about financial oversight and the security of funds intended for youth sports. The alleged misuse of such a significant amount could affect club operations, resources for players, and community trust in volunteer organizations.

Investigation Uncovers Financial Misconduct

The Manatee County Sheriff’s Office began its investigation, Case# 2026-013734, on June 29, 2026, after receiving notification of suspected financial fraud within the North Manatee Soccer Club. A club volunteer initially identified numerous transactions that appeared unrelated to the club's legitimate business. These suspicious purchases included expenses associated with Disney, a trip to Las Vegas, and various sporting events.

Details of Alleged Embezzlement Scheme

Detectives from the Economic Crimes unit discovered that Fetzner, starting in August 2023, deposited over $44,000 into a club sub-account using remote deposits. She also transferred nearly $102,000 from the club’s primary business account into this same sub-account. The investigation concluded that Fetzner used these funds from the sub-account to cover personal travel and living expenses. The total loss to the North Manatee Soccer Club from these alleged actions exceeds $146,000.

Arrest and Charges Filed

Following the investigation, Fetzner was arrested on an active warrant. She faces charges of Scheme to Defraud $50,000 or more. Immediately following her arrest, the North Manatee Soccer Club removed her from her position as treasurer.

Community Impact and Next Steps

The community now awaits further legal proceedings in this case. The North Manatee Soccer Club will likely need to address the financial shortfall and review its internal accounting practices to prevent similar incidents in the future. Residents involved with the club may seek information on how these events will affect upcoming seasons and club activities.